As the Keeper Factor changes, you may notice that a keeper's overall rating may be off by one or two points. This is normal; as you continue to play, after a time all keepers in their respective categories (ATG, Legend, Prime) will even out relative to one another.

Also please note that Keeper's Max overall will match the existing top rated Player's max overall in the game. If a keeper is of a lower Max ratting than that of a previous game versions this is likely the reason.